CHATHAM, VA -- President
Barack Obama yesterday nominated
Solicitor General Elena Kagan to the U.S. Supreme Court. While Rep. Tom
Perriello will not be forced to take a vote on her nomination,
Virginians
deserve to know if he supports the President's pick since the decisions
of
the next Supreme Court justice will have wide ramifications for each and
every
one of his constituents.
Because she has no judicial
experience - in fact, she'd be
the first justice in forty years without such a qualification - there
are few
clues as to her philosophy. But one aspect of her record is deeply
insightful,
and in state Sen. Robert Hurt's view, disqualifying. As the Dean of
Harvard Law
School, Ms. Kagan banned military recruiters from campus.
Hurt released the following
statement Tuesday expressing his
opinion on Kagan's nomination and calling on Rep. Perriello to do the
same:
"Solicitor General Kagan's
decision to bar military
recruiters from campus because she disagreed with The 'Don't Ask, Don't
Tell' policy - a policy with wide bipartisan support - signals a
left-wing worldview
that is out-of-touch with everyday Virginians. Someone who has proven
that they cannot put aside their political ideology for the sake of the
country's national security cannot be trusted to impartially evaluate
important
issues like the constitutionality of the president's healthcare bill or
the legality of the War on Terror. Voters deserve to
know if this nomination is just the latest in a long string of
presidential policies that Rep. Perriello blindly supports, or if he'll
finally exercise some independent thought and give voice to the scores
of
Virginians who no doubt object to Solicitor General Kagan's nomination."
NOTE: Peter Beinart, a
liberal political writer for
The Daily Beast, an associate professor of journalism and political
science at
City University of New York and a senior fellow at the New America
Foundation, wrote
on April 19 that, "The United States military is not Procter and Gamble.
It is
not just another employer. It is the institution whose members risk
their lives
to protect the country. You can disagree with the policies of the
American
military; you can even hate them, but you can't alienate yourself from
the
institution without in a certain sense alienating yourself from the
country.
Barring the military from campus is a bit like barring the president or
even
the flag. It's more than a statement of criticism; it's a statement of
national
estrangement."